Did Lewis Write Seven Planets?
Analyzing Michael Ward’s Planet Narnia thesis.
I recommended Michael Ward’s Planet Narnia some time ago, and I said that he “marshals enough argumentation to convince me he’s at least in the ballpark.” Today, I’ll be a little more specific. I’d like to present my current hypothesis, based on reading his book, on this article, on my own readings in Lewis, and on my experience as an author, a hypothesis that may or may not deserve to be called the ‘Weak Ward Hypothesis,’ the motte to Ward’s bailey.
Now, adopting Dickieson’s five-part summation of Ward’s hypothesis, as found in that linked article, I have no doubt at all on point one, that Lewis was interested in the imagery of the medieval cosmology; I’m literally in the process of memorizing Lewis’s The Planets. As an author, too, I’d expect that imagery to inform Narnia, and Ward marshals strong evidence to that end.
Of the final three points, #3 holds that Lewis intentionally shaped the Narniad according to the planetary imagery, and #4 refines this to be that Lewis focused on one planet in each book. Here I diverge summat from Dickieson, as I will in point 5, the question of whether, assuming such a structure exists, Lewis intentionally hid it from everybody around him, to the point of obscuring it behind other avowed structures for the septology.
As an author, I find a modified version of this theory to be plausible but not necessitated. Let’s start, therefore, with the minimum.
At minimum, I am convinced that Lewis intentionally incorporated planetary imagery, possibly not so pervasively as Ward presents- there is natural crossover between planetary imagery and imagery in general, so that the second could appear the first when looking for the first. Lewis being steeped in planetary imagery, of course, would cause it to pop up in his thought process and his writing as apposite and useful.
I do not, on the other hand, believe Lewis is at all proven to have structured the Narniad strictly according to planetary influenza (influence). The evidence does not require it, though it roughly permits it, when we remember that the planetary imagery is immensely broad and (which trouble both proof and disproof) interconnected. Jupiter cannot reach near to fullness entirely sans Venus or Mars or even Sol; Luna relies on Sol and Jupiter, to some extent; Mercury overlaps with Luna almost confusingly, while also conversing with the rest, and Saturn, as Ward presents him, stands counterpoint to most of the rest. Reaching the fullness of one influence would require the presence of the others, however backgrounded. The mixing Dickieson observes, therefore, does not prove Ward’s theory wrong, but Ward’s evidence does not prove it right.
When I enter the field of speculation, however, I can be a bit freer. I can easily see Lewis choosing to emphasis or lean on one particular planet- or a set of them- in a book; I can see also him choosing to do the same in another book of the series, except with a conscious choice not to repeat the identity of the planet emphasized. Each decision would be made on the prompting of the fitness of the planet to the story, and planets might even be left out or grouped, but the result could be something very similar to what Ward proposes, except without a premeditated structure.
It does raise the question of why Lewis did not mention it in his voluminous letter-writing, but it is easier to understand him not mentioning these particular choices in imagery than avoiding a fundamental structure of the books, particularly when we already have accepted that Lewis did indeed use planetary imagery without making real mention of it in his letters. The leap is only a little larger.
Another hypothesis, a bigger ask than this but still smaller than Ward’s, is that Lewis intentionally, pre-meditatedly structured the Narniad according to the seven planets (or chose to do so at some point relatively early in the writing, retroactively recognizing the first book or two as belonging to a particular planet whose imagery was naturally present in them), but that this structure was looser than Ward holds- an emphasis rather than a mandate.
Ultimately, I lack the expertise to say with certainty, and I doubt any man really could. Ward gets near certainty, as he presents himself, but he does not pretend his theory is impossible to deny. Dickieson acknowledges the vagueness. All my writing here is speculation, informed speculation, but speculation, and perhaps I err deeply in using my own writing experience as part of my model for Lewis’s proceedings. But if I do so, I’ll err once more to present a theory seeking to reconcile an intentional structure- or some softer version thereof- with Lewis’s silence.
In my own writings, many small details are scattered which I would have no hesitation in speaking of, were I asked rightly. They are not properly secrets. But, unless you showed that you understood a part of them already, I would not ever reveal them. I have hidden them, not to keep them secret but to see if I have hidden them well enough to be found. If somebody discovered, I would speak of it gladly; until somebody discovers, I will not speak or even hint. On this theory, the explanation for Lewis’s silence would be simple enough- nobody asked him, at least not in writing, and so he let the secret wait, not out of a mania for the cryptic but out of a desire that what was hidden should be honestly revealed.
God bless.
