Precedent Delenda Est
“Binding precedent” is antithetical to the foundations of America law.
For those unfamiliar, let me lay out the structure so that you can understand what I would cast away. In the current American legal system, when a court issues a decision, it ‘binds’ the courts below it (and certain courts equal to it) in its jurisdiction; it binds them to regard certain points of law expressed by that case as inflexible law. So if a Tennessee appeals court rules that the ‘premeditation’ in first degree murder requires not just time for reflection but actual, proven reflection, consideration of the murder intended (our homicide law is a convoluted mess of justice-evasion), then Tennessee trial courts under that appeals court have to regard that definition as written into the law, black-letter inflexibility.
The first objection to this system is that it’s a lie; it doesn’t work as advertised, and it works in a way unlike its advertisement.
If you read enough court cases, you’ll discover that a judge sufficiently motivated can twist precedent right on over onto its head. Sometimes it’s not hard; there’s a string of SCOTUS rulings which, taken in concert, plausibly imply the First Amendment protected status of political assassination, if you connect them up right. Sometimes, though, you can see the words straining and slithering to get the result the current judge wants. The real power of binding precedent is not in the formalistic demand that the lower court obey; it lies in the promise that a higher court will enforce it, meaning the lower court has to at least pay lip service to avoid being overturned.
In other words, if we had a system efficient enough to process cases quickly, if we had a legal code small enough to keep from bogging the courts down interminable (there’s another morasse!), then the role of ‘binding precedent’ could easily be taken over in its absence by the force which is its actual essence: the threat of a higher court reversing the lower court when it gets the law wrong. That would also require less reverence by judges for judges, a commodity supplied in hilarious excess of demand, as currently appeals generally turn on a ‘clear error’ doctrine, a subjective judgement by the higher judges (except when the judges can’t wiggle out of the precedent for fear of their next-up court whacking them on the noggin) on whether the lower judge’s error is big enough to bother the government.
The second objection is the greater, to my mind. Judges twist and turn the truth, having refined that skill in order to get the job, a concentrate mirror of current American morals. But binding precedent would not be solved by mere scrupulosity giving it force. No, ‘binding precedent’ is contrary, as it is applied, to the premise of American jurisprudence (law).
American law is premised on the rule of law over men. In theory, the Constitution, emplaced by the people (whether in accordance with Locke’s pretensions or Rutherford’s theology, as found in Genesis 9:5-6, I leave to you), the Constitution rules every part of the government, including the legislature. The legislature then makes laws, the executive enforces them, and the judges make sure that the law applied is the actual law. With variations in specifics, this structure repeats in every state government.
Fundamentally, here, America rejected the theory that the king was the law. In England, as Rushdoony recounts, the monarch stood above the law or rather identical with it, changing it according to his design (Politics of Guilt and Pity, P. II, Ch. 6). America rejected this incarnation; our laws rule our kings, not the other way round, because our kings are created by law, not its essence.
Binding precedent reverses that decision. Sovereign immunity, a product of ‘binding precedent,’ does something similar; it regards the king (the government) as above the law because the government is the law. Binding precedent instates that the government, meaning the persons who composed the institution (because an institution is composed of persons in relationship, nothing more), is the law. The judge says, and so….
Now, the legislature does the same, in a sense, and we’re just fine with that. Except, legislatures supposedly operate on grants of power; contra McCulloch v Maryland, one of SCOTUS’s all-time worsts (a strong statement!), ‘necessary and proper’ really is a limitation to what is necessary and what is proper, not a grant to go hog wild. The legislature is in effect given a law- that justice be done within a certain jurisdiction, that certain functions be fulfilled- and told to provide the details for everybody to enact. The judges were never granted that power by the law, by the Constitution. Indeed, they arrogated it to themselves, in such striking instances as Marbury v Madison.
There, SCOTUS declared that because it could only enforce a Constitutional law (correct), it must render verdicts on what was Constitutional (correct). The implication, as taken by American government ever since, is that SCOTUS decides what the Constitution is; the justices on that bench have the unilateral right of amendment, restrained only by public opinion, a need to maintain at least minimal credibility, and the fear that Congress will remember the impeachment power. Article V may purport to establish the only means of changing the Constitution- but the Constitution is a law, and judges decide what the law is.
Binding precedent is contrary to American law because binding precedent allows the one enforcing the law to decide what the law is. On a case by case basis, of course, the one applying the law has to do that; interpretation is integral to obedience. But binding precedent makes one group’s interpretations act as changes to the law, rather than individual interpretations or wise examples. In the American law system, we ought to be bound by the statutes, then by the Constitution, and then (let us be true to God) by Scripture, with each layer overruling the most pretentious judge in an instant, unless he can marshal in truth a higher law to reject the lower. Instead, in binding precedent, the judge speaks and that is it. The judge’s word is the law, let the law itself say what it says.
As SCOTUS Justice Stone said in 1936, “… the only check upon our own exercise of power is our own sense of self-restraint.” Rex lex, in other words, and yet…. The Lord on high is King over all, and His law is without stay.
God bless.